AlephBeta Logo
  • Home
  • Patron Circle
My List
Your list is waiting
Add Torah lessons you want to reflect on, revisit, or binge later.
Upgrade to All Access

Unlock all videos, transcripts, and study materials.

Start Free Trial
AlephBeta Logo

Stay Connected

Follow Aleph Beta on social media

InstagramTikTokFacebookYouTubePodcastsSpotify

About Us

  • About
  • Careers
  • Weekly Parsha

Our Team

  • Team

Get Help

  • Contact

Support Us

  • Subscribe
  • Educators
  • Shop
  • Donate
AlephBeta Logo

A Nonprofit Media Company helping people closely read the Torah to discover its beauty, meaning and relevance

Cookies Policy
Legal Terms
Privacy Policy

© 2026 Aleph Beta. All rights reserved.

HomeSearchProfile
Back

Punished...By Snakes?



We know that God is just, and when He punishes us, the punishment always fits the crime – what the Sages call מדה כנגד מדה, measure for measure. God’s actions are always proportionate and fair.

Parshat Chukat really puts that belief to the test. The Israelites complain about the manna – and God sends poisonous snakes to attack them. Is that a fair and just response? That doesn't sound מדה כנגד מדה.

But maybe that's because we're misunderstanding the real crime and the real punishment here. What if the people weren't really complaining about the manna? And what if God didn't really send snakes to attack the people?

Join Daniel Loewenstein as he analyzes the story of the snakes in the wilderness, and suggests there's a different story hiding in the details – a story that has something important to teach us, today. And no, it’s not about how to react when our kids don’t like what’s for dinner – it’s actually about what it means to be independent.

Click here to watch "Where It All Went Wrong."